Fishtales Bar & Grill

Reviews about Fishtales Bar & Grill

• 1 / 5

  By Keith Shannon
  Went there for the first time since we got a mailing with a $10 off coupon. Not a good reason to choose a restaurant! Was apprehensive due to the hit or miss quality I've experienced at Schermerhorns and the mixed Yelp reviews. WOW, was this a miss. Lobster bisque was cold and the only thing that made it worse was how it tasted. Clam chowder was actually pretty good. Steamers, I'm hoping they were cooked (they were hot and open, so that's a good sign...) as they were slimy and often gritty. The lobster was cooked well, though it took me a bit to get my appetite back after the sour cream came out WITH MOLD ON IT. The server was nice, took it back and brought out some new sour cream for us. There was an apology but no offer to comp anything or make up for this health code violation in any way. The server was nice, but that doesn't make up for the rest. Now just hoping we don't get sick...
  
  UPDATE-My wife and I have been sick all night.
  March 23, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Cammy Thurber
  The bestest food ever, and the best prices.
  June 16, 2016